I am starting this blog because I spend way too much time on the internet and my mind wanders, and I figured a blog would be a good way to get all my thoughts down and hopefully focus them in the process. I found myself posting things on Facebook, which would go into my friends' news feeds, and I would much rather not bother everyone with things I find interesting. This way, only people who are actually interested in what I think about things (which may be no one!) will be burdened. This will really be less of a "what's happening in my real life" blog than "what's happening in my dilettante life." For the most part, I imagine I'll talk about TV shows and movies, books and music, but also politics and perhaps even some more philosophical musings. Haha! Reader beware!
Right now I'm trying to write the second chapter of my thesis, and because I'm such a scatter-brain, it's taking quite a bit longer than I anticipated. I've been re-watching Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, and it's still really good and relevant. I started again because I was thinking about how John McCain said that the US could be in Iraq for another hundred years, and on the surface that doesn't seem like such an unreasonable thing to say. There are still American troops in Korea, Japan, Germany, and other places, but not in combat roles. However, it does seem that the conflicts that led to those long-term deployments were quaititatively different than what's going on in the Middle East right now. What's good about DS9 (and other STs too, but this one does it best) is isolate certain elements of different cultures and then explore them in depth, over many episodes. Indeed, most of the series is the same war, and the bad guys aren't totally bad, the good guys often do unethical things.
The other thing I've been thinking about, not extensively though, is what's going on in Zimbabwe. I saw an episode of DS9 in which a former Federation officer turned terrorist/freedom fighter tells Captain Sisko that the Federation is worse than the Borg, because at least the Borg tell you up front that you're going to be assimilated and that resistance is futile. The Federation makes you think that you're advancing the cause of liberal democracy and egalitarianism, but they're really incorporating you into their ideology. Whatever you think of that (the Federation utopia seems pretty good), it's an interesting thing to consider. Isn't that what Zizek is always going on about? His new book (In Defense of Lost Causes) seems to be about that, at least in part, in terms of the perils of liberal democracies. Mugabe holding elections, and forcing people to vote, seems to be an extreme version of this: I'm not going to be your run-of-the-mill dictator, I'm going to make you endorse me. Of course, if you don't have a purple finger to show you've voted (really only one name is available), you'll be punished. Does it somehow make you nostalgic for the good old days when dictators didn't need such validation?
Why am I writing this blog instead of my thesis? Well, sometimes everyone needs a break. Though mine seems to have lasted 3 days. I ought to do some research tonight at least...anticipate the next chapter!
seoulonice
12 years ago
5 comments:
Ok, well I have a question for you, in defense of the Federation. Doesn't advancing a cause usually entail advancing ideology? Is the Federation actually misleading people, or is it just misleading those who choose not to recognize the ideologies that govern liberal democracies? And don't those people deserve what's coming to them -- involvement in many Star Trek spinoffs...?
Oh yeah I think the Federation is fine, as utopias go. I mean, I don't see how their economy is really viable, but that's another story. I mean, the dialectic goes on, just on a larger (galactic) scale. I think Eddington's point was that the Federation doesn't frame it as advancing ideology (and that's what Zizek is saying too), they make it seem like they're liberating everyone and giving them free choices. But the truth is that there are lots of diverse cultures and the Federation basically dilutes them into liberal democracies (for example, the Klingons could never join the Federation, there's too much violence, etc--but they can be close allies). Now, as someone who likes liberal democracies, I think that's OK. You should take a look at Zizek's new book--he's gone way more extreme in his old(er) age (and he has many more years to get even crankier).
Yeah, I read Zizek's intro to Mao's writings and that was really interesting.
I get that it seems like the Federation is hiding their agenda. But I think that their agenda is so transparent that it's almost impossible *not* to get. Politics thrive on ideology, and the Federation is a political body. It's hard for me to believe that one could join a body like the Federation without realizing what that membership entails, regardless of the Federation's own propaganda.
I don't think the Federation is so bad. I was just bringing up what Eddington said in that episode...
:-)
Oh no! I love the Federation. But it is a federation...
Post a Comment